The Crestwood Board of Aldermen has officially passed an ordinance to establish a conservation overlay district in the city’s Ridgewood neighborhood.
Ridgewood homeowners who are building homes from scratch or undergoing large renovations will now be subject to a series of additional construction guidelines, intended to preserve the mid-century modern architecture of the neighborhood.
“We are here not just to solve problems, but to preserve an opportunity,” Ward 2 Alderperson Rebecca Now said at the board’s Oct. 27 meeting. “The opportunity is to have a special district that has an architectural style that is appreciated and historical. (…) I think it is something we’ll regret not doing.”
The ordinance passed with six ayes. Ward 1 Alderman Jesse Morrison, a Ridgewood resident and vocal supporter of the overlay district, was absent; Ward 3 Alderman Grant Mabie was the sole “nay” vote.
“I do think this ordinance is a solution in search of a problem,” Mabie said on Oct. 27. “I’m not seeing a reason to prohibit the freedom of redevelopment in these homes. I fear that we are permanently reducing the property values of everyone who lives in Ridgewood if we impose these special restrictions that are not present elsewhere in the city.”
He added, “I think it’s hubris on our part to substitute our architectural judgment for the freedom of the judgment of hundreds of current and future Ridgewood homeowners who might be interested in buying there. I think property rights are one of our cherished American traditions and I’d be loath to restrict those without a good reason to do so.”
The ordinance creates roofing requirements: only gable roofs may be used, and the roof pitch must not exceed a maximum slope of 2:12. There are also specific measurement requirements for roof eaves.
Ridgewood homes will not be able to exceed two stories or 25 feet, whichever is higher, and maximum wall heights were established for exterior walls. Doors, windows and fireplaces will not be allowed to be centered directly below the ridge of the gable roof. Exterior fireplaces also need to conform to specific measurements and materials.
Homeowners will not need to make changes to existing properties, but any homes built in the future will be required to meet these guidelines. Homeowners remodeling or expanding their home would also need to follow these standards if the renovation or expansion would exceed 400 square feet and be “readily visible” from the street at the midpoint of the lot.
“As an architect, I get to deal with all sorts of design review around the area. This is a fairly light touch as far as any sort of design review,” Ward 1 Alderman Jim Zavist said. “Part of it is putting an ordinance in place and seeing if it works. If it doesn’t work, we can change it.”
The ordinance was passed with one amendment, put forward by Mabie. The exterior wall height’s maximum on two- or one-and-a-half-story homes was originally set to not exceed 18 feet; the board voted to increase that maximum to 20 feet. Now voted against Mabie’s amendment, while Morrison was marked absent.